We are proud of our long history of successfully defending our clients in court. Below are a number of Jury Verdicts achieved by our firm while representing defendants in Civil lawsuits. Most, if not all, of the cases summarized below were published by "The Verdict Reporter" which includes cases from all jurisdictions from Connecticut as well as Massachusetts and Rhode Island. We have separted the cases outlined below by Judicial District.
Danbury Judicial District
Restaurant Not Liable for Collision
Jennifer Burke vs. Aura Showah d/b/a Widow Brown's Cafe
Case Number: DBD CV 06 5001540
Danbury Superior Court
Facts: On September 26, 2006, the plaintiff, Jennifer Burke, was operating her vehicle on Federal Road in Danbury, Connecticut when she was struck by a vehicle operated by Eugene Williams. Mr. Williams had been exiting the parking lot of the defendant Widow Brown's Cafe when the collision occurred. Mr. Williams had been a patron at the establishment and had breathylyzer test reults of .272 and .279 while in police custody. The defendant admitted that Mr. Williams had been a patron, but denied that he had been visibly intoxicated.
Plaintiff Profile: The Plaintiff was a 33 year old marketing consultant and homemaker.
Alleged Injury: The plaintiff claimed a 7% and 10 % PPD of the cervical and lumber spines, respectively, with a herniated disc in the lumbar spine. Past and future medical specials totalled $18,496. The plaintiff claimed an additional $15,000 in lost wages.
Plaintiff's Experts: Ralph Santora, Chiropractor
Settlement Efforts: The original demand of $250,000 representing the Dram Shop Act limit was reduced to $150,000 during jury selection.
Judge: Deborah Frankel Date of Verdict: 6/01/2007
Plaintiff's Attorneys: Colleen Fries and James Coyne
Defendant's Attorney: Jan Trendowski
Jury Deliberations: 55 minutes
Verdict: Defense Verdict
Editor’s Note: The alleged intoxicated driver, Eugene Williams, was sued separately and settled out prior to trial. The case was not appealed.
_______________________________________________________________________________
Club Not Liable For Patron’s Injuries
Tiffany Vail vs. Ives Street Corporation
Case Number: CV04-4000946
Danbury Superior Court
Facts: On April, 26, 2003, the plaintiff, Tiffany Vail, was a patron at the defendant’s night club. The plaintiff claimed she was forcibly removed from the premises by the defendant’s security and physically ejected, causing her to fall and sustain injuries. The defendant argued that the plaintiff was violent and intoxicated. The defendant further argued that the plaintiff fell due to her intoxicated state after being escorted to the front door.
Plaintiff Profile: The plaintiff was a 26 year old homemaker.
Alleged Injury: The plaintiff claimed aggravations of pre-existing cervical and lumbar injuries requiring surgery to repair existing surgical hardware in the neck and back. Medical specials were $80,000 incurred at the time of trial with $150,000 in future specials for lumbar surgery. Cervical surgery had been completed at time of trial.
Settlement Efforts: Last Demand: $850,000 Last Offer: None
Judge: Deborah Frankel Date of Verdict: 7/6/2006
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): Philip Spillane, Newtown
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Jan C. Trendowski, Centerbrook
Jury Deliberation: 5 hours
Verdict: Defense verdict
_______________________________________________________________________________
Homeowners Not Responsible for Painter’s Fall Off Deck
Frederick Witte vs. William Murphy and Edna Murphy
Case Number: CV03-0350822
Danbury Superior Court
Facts: A painter who fell off the deck of a house and allegedly suffered multiple injuries claimed negligence by the defendant homeowners. However, after only 45 minutes of deliberation, a Danbury jury returned a defense verdict for the homeowners. Plaintiff Frederick Witte was hired by Defendants William and Edna Murphy to clean and paint the deck attached to their home. While powerwashing the deck, plaintiff fell off the deck to the ground approximately 23' below. Plaintiff alleged that defendants had negligently maintained the deck and that the deck constituted a nuisance. Plaintiff further alleged that defendants did not have a building permit for the deck. Plaintiff claimed to have suffered a fractured right clavicle and hip, fractured ribs, a punctured lung and soft tissue injuries to his shoulder, neck, low back and ankle, resulting in permanent impairment.
Defendants denied liability. Defendants contended that the deck was already attached to the house when they bought it and that plaintiff was hired to maintain it for them. Defendants further contended that plaintiff’s explanation of how he fell did not make sense and that some of plaintiff’s problems were pre-existing.
Plaintiff Profile: Plaintiff was a 50 year old single white male employed as a painter.
Alleged Injury: Fractured right clavicle, hip and ribs and punctured lung. Secondary soft tissue injuries to shoulder, neck, low back and ankle. Plaintiff was assigned permanency ratings of 7% to the hip, 5% to the shoulder and 5% to the lower back. He claimed $17,478 in past medical specials and $16,791 in past wage loss.
Plaintiff Experts: Manoni, Ronald G., D.C. ; Deveney, Robert T., M.D. ; Skolnick, Matthew D., M.D.; Blick, Gary, M.D.
Defendant Experts: Lord, Jason M., D.C.
Settlement Efforts: Last Demand: $68,500 (judicial pretrial recommendation)
Last Offer: $50,000
Judge: Michael E. Shay Date of Verdict: 4/18/2005
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): James Wu, Danbury
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Gregory A. Allen, Centerbrook
Jury Deliberations: 45 minutes
Verdict: Defense verdict
Editor’s Note: A motion to set aside judgment was denied and the case is closed.
Fairfield Judicial District
Dram Shop Liability - Restaurant - Patron Assaulted
Corey Cannone v. Edward Chittenden, Inc., et al
Case Number: CV97-0342985s
Bridgeport Superior Court
Facts: Plaintiff was in the parking lot of Defendant Sidetrack’s restaurant in Fairfield when he was knifed by an allegedly intoxicated patron. Immediately prior to the incident the perpetrator had consumed several shots and beers at defendant's restaurant. Plaintiff alleged that: (1) the perpetrator was intoxicated; (2) defendant was negligent in serving a patron who is visibly intoxicated; and (3) the perpetrator was acting out of character prior to the incident and assaulted him without warning. Defendant contended that the perpetrator did not consume sufficient alcohol on the premises to be intoxicated.
Plaintiff's Profile: Plaintiff was a 23 year old single white male who was employed as a car detailer.
Alleged Injury: Injury to right (dominant) hand with residual scarring resulting in 10% permanent partial disability of right hand. Plaintiff claimed $750 in medical specials.
Settlement Efforts: Last Demand: $15,000 Last Offer: $ 2,500
Judge: Myron R. Ballen Date of Verdict: 6/99
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): Paul C. Gusmano, Bridgeport
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Jan C. Trendowski, Centerbrook
Jury Deliberations: 25 minutes
Verdict: Defense Verdict
Hartford Judicial District
Pedestrians Struck by Vehicle Are Found 49% Comparatively Negligent
Jo Broder and Jamie Broder v. Charles Burt and Donald Burt
Case Number: CV00-0803041
Hartford Superior Court
Facts: A mother and daughter who were injured when they were struck by a vehicle were found 49% comparatively negligent by a Hartford Jury. On June 2, 1999, plaintiff pedestrians, Jo Broder, a 61 year old female, and her daughter Jamie Broder, age 31, were walking in a marked crosswalk on North Main Street in West Hartford. They were struck by a vehicle driven by Defendant Charles Burt and owned by Defendant Ronald Burt. The accident occurred at dusk. Plaintiff had prior and subsequent accidents. Plaintiffs alleged that they were in a marked crosswalk and crossing with the “walk” signal when they were struck. Both plaintiffs claimed to have suffered soft tissue injuries with permanencies. Defendants contended that Charles was driving at 10 mph and had a green light, but the plaintiffs ran into his path. The jury awarded $251,259 to Jo Broder, which was reduced to $128,142 Jamie Broder’s award of $50,625 was reduced to $25,819.
Plaintiff Profile: Plaintiff Jo was a 61 year old married female who was a real estate broker. Plaintiff Jamie was a 31 year old single female who worked in media advertising.
Alleged Injury: Jo - soft tissue right knee (10% ppd), right shoulder (7% ppd) and neck (5% ppd injuries, temporomandibular joint dysfunction (TMJ) and a 15% whole person impairment. She claimed past medical expenses of $34,324, future medical expenses of $20,500 and lost wages of $100,000. Jamie - soft tissue back and right knee injuries. She claimed $15,372 in past medical expenses and no lost wages.
Plaintiff's Experts: John Rosenlieb, D.M.D. Dentist - W. Hartford, CT ; David S. Silvers, M.D. Neurologist - Hartford, CT ; Ronald J. Trapana, M.D. Orthopedist - Hollywood, FL ; John J. O’Brien, M.D. Orthopedist - Hartford, CT
Settlement Efforts: Last Demand $250,000 (Jo); $90,000 (Jamie)
Last Offer: $82,000 (Jo); $60,000 (Jamie)
Judge: Marshall K. Berger, Jr. Date of Verdict: 12/13/2002
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): Alan J. Rome, W. Hartford
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Jan C. Trendowski, Centerbrook
Jury Deliberations: 7 hours
Verdict: $301,884 less 49% comparative negligence for a new verdict of $153,961. Breakdown: $251,259 to Jo Broder ($51,259 in economic damages; $200,000 in non-economic damages) and $50,625 to Jamie Broder ($15,375 in economic damages; $35,250 in non-economic damages).
Editor's Note: Plaintiff’s motion to set aside verdict was denied.
_______________________________________________________________________________
Auto Accident - Turning - Right-of-Way
Randy Guadauskos v. Margaret Moniz
Case Number: CV92-0518894
Hartford Superior Court
Facts: Plaintiff and defendant were traveling in opposite directions. Defendant made a left turn into the path of plaintiff’s oncoming vehicle, resulting in a collision between the front portion of plaintiff’s auto and rear-end of defendant’s vehicle. Plaintiff had a pre-existing tachycardiac condition which had been under control prior to the accident. Two months after this collision, plaintiff had to be hospitalized for tachycardia. Plaintiff alleged that defendant was negligent in failing to yield the right-of-way and that he suffered a heart contusion in the collision which aggravated his pre-existing tachycardiac condition, requiring hospitalization. Defendant contended that plaintiff was comparatively negligent in failing to keep a proper lookout and in failing to avoid a collision.
Plaintiff Profile: Plaintiff was a single white male in his 20's, employed as an accountant.
Alleged Injury: Heart contusion resulting in aggravation of pre-existing tachycardiac condition, requiring hospitalization and permanent increase in medications. Plaintiff claimed $24,000 in medical specials.
Plaintiff's Experts: Michael A. Rossi, M.D. - Cardiovascular Disease - Hartford, CT ; Thomas B. Graboys, M.D. - Cardiovascular Disease - Brookline, MA ;
Defendant's Expert: Arthur V. McDowell, M.D. - Cardiovascular Disease - Middletown, CT
Settlement Efforts: Last Demand: $175,000 Last Offer: $60,001
Judge: Norris L. O’Neill Date of Verdict: 2/16/96
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): Francis C. Vignati, Jr., East Hartford
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Jan C. Trendowski, Cromwell
Jury Deliberations: 4 hours
Verdict: $87,000 less 30% comparative negligence yielded a net verdict of $60,900.
Middlesex Judicial District
VFW Found Not Liable for Underage Drinker’s Death
Debra Shafer, Adm. vs. Frederick Sullivan, et al
Case Number: X04 CV04 4000817
Middletown Superior Court
Facts: A high speed police pursuit resulted in the death of a 20 year old man. The young man’s estate claimed decedent’s consumption of alcohol at a Halloween party sponsored by the Veterans of Foreign Wars (VFW) post caused his death. The VFW denied liability and argued that decedent’s own negligence caused the tragic events. A Middlesex jury returned a defense verdict after 6 hours of deliberation. Plaintiff, Debra Shafer, was the Administratrix of the Estate of Andrew Shafer, a minor. Andrew Shafer was involved in a motor vehicle accident while attempting to flee from a police vehicle. He died as a result of his accident injuries. Plaintiff had been at a Halloween party at Defendant Frederick Sullivan Post VFW. Decedent had a blood alcohol content of .14 at his time of death. Defendant admitted plaintiff’s decedent was at the party, but claimed decedent consumed alcohol prior to entering its premises. Defendant contended decedent brought his own beer to the party. Defendant further argued that decedent was negligent in operating his vehicle with a bent axle and failing to stop for the police. Defendant maintained the plaintiff’s decedent contributed to his death by operating a vehicle under the influence of alcohol and engaging in a high speed pursuit with law enforcement officials.
Plaintiff Profile: Plaintiff’s decedent was a 20 year old single male employed as an auto service manager.
Alleged Injury: Blunt force trauma resulting in death. Decedent’s annual income at the time of death was $17,000. He was survived by his mother.
Settlement Efforts: Last Demand: $2,000,000 ; Last Offer: $20,000
Judge: Julia L. Aurigemma Date of Verdict: 6/12/2006
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): Brian W. Prucker, Vernon
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Jan C. Trendowski, Centerbrook
Jury Deliberation: 6 hours
Verdict: Defense verdict
New Britain Judicial District
Auto/Motorcycle Accident - Intersection - Stop Sign
Richard Luther v. Eugene Tillay
Case Number: CV99-0495012
New Britain Superior Court
Facts: Plaintiff motorcyclist and defendant motorist were operating their respective vehicles on intersecting streets. Defendant proceeded into an intersection from a stop sign and struck plaintiff motorcyclist, who did not have a stop sign. Plaintiff alleged that: (1) defendant failed to yield the right-of-way; (2) defendant’s view was not obstructed; and (3) he had a mild traumatic brain injury with permanent impairments as a direct result of this accident. Defendant contended that plaintiff was contributorily negligent in that he had been drinking prior to the accident. Defendant also contended that plaintiff had multiple prior head injuries and chronic substance abuse problems.
Plaintiff Profile: Plaintiff was a 38 year old single male who was a construction worker.
Alleged Injury: Primary injuries consisted of mild traumatic brain injury with permanent impairments to memory, concentration and executive functions, headaches and a 5% whole body impairment. Secondary injuries consisted of soft tissue neck injury consisting of a 5% impairment of the cervical spine. Plaintiff claimed $9,517 in past medicals, $4,160 in future medicals. He was disabled from working due to unrelated reasons
Plaintiff's Witnesses: Kenneth W. Gilstein, Ph.D. - Neuropsychologist - Guilford CT
Settlement Efforts: Last Demand: $80,000 ; Last Offer: $50,000
Judge: Barbara M. Quinn Date of Verdict: 2/27/02
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): Mark Migliaccio, Hartford
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Jan C. Trendowski, Centerbrook
Jury Deliberations: 4 hours
Verdict: $12,617. Breakdown: $3,000 for pain and suffering and $9,617 for past medical expenses.
Editor’s Note: Per defense counsel, plaintiff’s prior medical history had an impact on the outcome.
________________________________________________________________________________
Premises Liability - Falldown - Husband Sues Wife
Louis Raffanello v. Jean Raffanello
Case Number: CV99-0493422
New Britain Superior Court
Facts: Plaintiff Louis slipped and fell on ice at his residence. The property was owned by plaintiff’s wife, Defendant Jean. Plaintiff alleged that: (1) defendant failed to maintain the property; (2) defendant owed a duty to the plaintiff as an invitee; and (3) plaintiff gave monthly payments to defendant wife for room and board, making him a tenant of the property. Defendant contended that the monthly payments were contributions to the household, not rent, and plaintiff had joint control of the premises.
Plaintiff Profile: Plaintiff was a 76 year old married male who was retired.
Alleged Injury: Primary injury consisted of cervical cord compression in neck requiring discectomy and fusion which resulted in a 30% permanent partial disability of the neck. Secondary injury consisted of neurological injury resulting in incontinence and a 20% permanent partial disability. Plaintiff claimed $61,789 in medical specials.
Settlement Efforts: Last Demand: $120,000 ; Last Offer: $10,000
Judge: James T. Graham Date of Verdict: 3/22/01
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): Gary D. Constant, Bristol
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Jan C. Trendowski, Centerbrook
Jury Deliberations: 25 minutes
Verdict: Defense Verdict
Editor’s Note: Per defense counsel, plaintiff was not credible on the room and board issue.
New Haven Judicial District
Driver Entering Roadway Not Liable
Case Caption: James Delvecchio vs. Jennifer Voskov
Case Number: CV 02 279249
Plaintiff Profile: Plaintiff was a 51-year-old insurance agent.
Alleged Injury: The plaintiff claimed a 14% permanent partial disability of the cervical spine with radiating pain into both arms and an aggravation of a pre-existing lumbar condition. Medical specials totaled $10,672.16.
Settlement Efforts: Last Demand: $100,000 ; Last Offer: $0
Judge: Brian T. Fischer Date of Verdict: 01/31/03
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): Bruce Chaplin, Durham
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Jan C. Trendowski, Centerbrook
Jury Deliberations: 3 hours
Verdict: Defense Verdict
________________________________________________________________________________
Pedestrian Fails to Convince Jury of Motorist’s Liability for Soft Tissue Injuries
Sonia Villeda v. Gerald O'Sullivan
Case Number: CV00-0441207
New Haven Superior Court
Facts: A New Haven jury rejected the injury claim of a pedestrian who acknowledged that she attempted to cross a street in front of an oncoming vehicle although she knew that the motorist did not have a traffic control device directing him to stop. A defense verdict was entered after 1 hour and 50 minutes of deliberation. Plaintiff pedestrian, Sonia Villeda, was crossing a street at night while it was raining. Defendant Gerald O’Sullivan, who was operating a vehicle on the same street, struck plaintiff. There was no traffic control device at the location where plaintiff was crossing. Plaintiff, a 37 year old female, alleged that defendant failed to yield the right-of-way to a pedestrian. Plaintiff also claimed to have suffered various soft tissue injuries and a 5% permanent partial disability to her back. Defendant contended that plaintiff walked out in front of his oncoming car despite seeing him approaching and despite knowing that defendant motorist did not have a stop sign or stop light.
Plaintiff Profile: Plaintiff was a 37 year old married Hispanic female.
Alleged Injury: Soft tissue neck, back, right arm and shoulder injuries. Plaintiff was assigned a 5% permanent partial disability to her lumbar spine. She claimed $10,300 in medical expenses and $620 in lost wages.
Plaintiff's Expert: Efraim Gomez, M.D. Internal Medicine - Stamford
Settlement Efforts: Last Demand: $50,000; Last offer: $20,000
Judge: Thomas J. Corradino Date of Verdict: 10/3/2003
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): Gregory E. O’Brien, Cheshire
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Gregory A. Allen, Centerbrook
Jury Deliberations: 1 hour, 50 minutes
Verdict: Defense Verdict
New London Judicial District
Award to Passenger Injured in Auto Accident is Reduced Under the Apportionment Statute
Timothy Smith v. Curtis Carlough
Case Number: CV02-0560969
New London Superior Court
Facts: A man was awarded $15,000 by a New London jury for injuries he sustained in a motor vehicle accident. The award, however, was reduced by 40% under the apportionment statute. Plaintiff Timothy Smith was a rear seat passenger in a vehicle driven by John McIntyre. Defendant Curtis Carlough was operating his own vehicle on the same road and in the same direction as the plaintiff. Driver McIntyre came to a stop at a traffic light and was subsequently rear-ended by defendant. There was no apparent damage to either vehicle. Plaintiff alleged that defendant caused the accident in failing to keep a proper lookout. Plaintiff further claimed to have suffered permanent injuries as a result of defendant’s negligence. Defendant Carlough named John McIntyre as an apportionment defendant and alleged that McIntyre contributed to the accident by making a sudden and unreasonable stop. According to Defendant Carlough, he came to an uneventful stop behind McIntyre at a red light. McIntyre reportedly began to proceed through the intersection and was rear-ended by Carlough when McIntyre stopped suddenly and unexpectedly a second time. Defendant also argued that plaintiff’s injuries were not as serious as he claimed. The jury apportioned 40% liability to McIntyre and 60% liability to Defendant Carlough.
Plaintiff Profile: Plaintiff was a 22 year old single white male who was employed as a store clerk.
Alleged Injury: Soft tissue neck and back injuries requiring chiropractic treatment and resulting in a 5% impairment of the cervico-thoracic junction and an 8% impairment of the lumbar spine. Plaintiff claimed $4,089 in past medical expenses (including $3,790 in chiropractic expenses) $23,850 in future medical expenses and no lost wages.
Plaintiff's Expert: Michael R. Thomas, D.C. Chiropractor - Groton, CT
Settlement Efforts: Last Demand See Editor’s Note. ; Last Offer: $2,000
Judge: Thomas J. Corradino Date of Verdict: 2/6/2003
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): Stephen E. Reck, New London
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Gregory A. Allen, Centerbrook
Jury Deliberations: 1 hour, 10 minutes
Verdict: $15,000 less apportionment of 40% for a new verdict of $9,000.
Editor's Note: Per plaintiff’s counsel, the lasts settlement demand was $18,000. Defense counsel, however, indicated that the last demand was $46,000. Defense counsel also reported that plaintiff brought a second case directly against John McIntyre alleging that the same injuries at issue in the case at hand were caused by McIntyre and not Defendant Carlough. The case against McIntyre was still pending at the time of editing this case for publication. Plaintiff’s counsel reported that there was a three month gap in treatment between plaintiff’s emergency room visit and his chiropractic treatment.
_______________________________________________________________________________
Anthony Alfiero v. The Great American Insurance
Case Number: CV02-0560942
New London Superior Court
Facts: An elderly man’s claim that he was permanency injured in a motor vehicle accident was rejected by a New London jury. Plaintiff Anthony Alfiero, a 72 year old male, was involved in a motor vehicle accident. Plaintiff settled with the tortfeasor’s insurance carrier for its policy limits of $20,000 and pursued this claim against his underinsured motorist carrier, Defendant Great American. Liability was admitted. Plaintiff alleged that he suffered severe and permanent disabling injuries as a result of the accident and that his damages exceeded the tortfeasor’s policy limits of $20,000. Defendant contended that plaintiff’s disabilities were not caused by the accident and his injuries and treatment were inconsistent with them being caused by the underlying accident.
Plaintiff Profile: Plaintiff was a 72 year old married white male who was retired.
Alleged Injury: Lumbar disc herniation in back and soft tissue injuries to right wrist and right knee. Plaintiff was assigned a 5% permanent impairment to the right leg and a 13% whole person impairment due to the lumbar disc herniation. He claimed past medical expenses of $2,836, future medical expenses of $60,000 and no lost wages.
Plaintiff's Expert Witness: Joseph P. Zeppieri, M.D.
Defendant's Expert Witness: Andrew J. Hallberg, M.D.
Settlement Efforts: Last Demand: $80,000 ; Last Offer: $2,500
Judge: Seymour L. Hendel Date of Verdict: 12/19/2002
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): Steven M. Laput, New London
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Gregory A. Allen, Centerbrook
Jury Deliberations: 2 ½ hours
Verdict: Defense Verdict
Editor's Note: Per defense counsel, the uncertainty of plaintiff’s expert regarding causation of the Plaintiff's medical problems and plaintiff’s sporadic treatment had an impact on the outcome.
Tolland Judicial District
Landlord/Tenant - Burn - Steam Radiator
Nicole McGrath v. Stephen Jackson, et al.
Case Number: CV91-0049343S
Tolland Superior Court
Facts: Plaintiff, a 16 year-old female, was a tenant in a residence owned by defendants. While standing in the bathroom, plaintiff lost consciousness due to an illness and fell against a steam radiator, suffering second and third degree burns across her shoulder blades. Plaintiff alleged that defendants were negligent in failing to provide a cover and safety valve on the radiator, in failing to warn of the danger and in failing to properly maintain the radiator. Defendants contended that the residence was properly maintained and that the radiator was operating as designed. Defendants further contended that installing a cover was not reasonable and that plaintiff’s accident was unforeseeable.
Plaintiff Profile: Plaintiff was a 16 year old single white female, employed as a clerk.
Alleged Injury: Second and third degree burns on back (across the shoulder blades) with substantial unrevised scarring approximately the size of a shoe box. Plaintiff claimed $19,400 in past medical specials and $30,000.00 in future medical expenses.
Plaintiff's Experts: Harold Beam, M.D. - Plastic Surgeon - Rockville CT ; Gilbert Nichols - Engineer - Hartford CT
Defendant's Expert: Nelson Gottier - Heating Installation - Rockville CT
Settlement Efforts: Last Demand: $275,000 ; Last Offer: $50,000
Judge: Thomas A. Bishop Date of Verdict: 2/22/96
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): Mitchell E. Kallet, Vernon
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Jan C. Trendowski, Cromwell
Jury Deliberations: 50 minutes
Verdict: Defense Verdict
Waterbury Judicial District
Truck/Pedestrian Accident - Minor Wandering Into Road
Samantha Vandine v. Timothy J. Marley
Case Number: CV 950124656 S
Waterbury Superior Court
Facts: Plaintiff, a two and a half year old girl, allegedly wandered into the road from behind a parked truck and was struck by a pickup truck operated by the defendant.
Plaintiff alleged that she was behind the parked truck, but was in full view of defendant, and that defendant was negligent in failing to keep a proper lookout.
Defendant contended that: (1) he was familiar with the neighborhood; (2) he was keeping a proper lookout while traveling approximately 10 to 13 m.p.h.; and (3) he could not have been more careful.
Plaintiff Profile: Plaintiff was a two and a half year old girl.
Plaintiff's Expert: Edmund Sullivan - Accident Reconstruction - Waterbury, CT
Settlement Efforts: Last Demand: $90,000 ; Last Offer: $25,000
Judge: Joseph H. Pellegrino Date of Verdict: 7/9/98
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): Robert Nastri, Jr., Waterbury
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Jan C. Trendowski, Centerbrook
Verdict: Defense Verdict
Editor's Note: Per defendant’s counsel, defendant was very credible. He was sincerely remorseful that plaintiff had been injured, although he was not at fault. Case is closed.
Windham Judicial District
Auto Accident - Rear-End - Underinsured Motorist Claim
John Fikiet v. American National Fire Insurance Co.
Case Number: CV97056950S
Putnam Superior Court
Facts: Plaintiff’s vehicle was rear-ended by a third party who had $20,000 policy limits. After the policy was exhausted, plaintiff filed this claim against Defendant American National Fire Insurance Company pursuant to his underinsured motorist coverage. Defendant admitted liability and the trial proceeded on the issue(s) of proximate cause and/or damages. Plaintiff alleged that he suffered thoracic outlet syndrome and soft tissue neck, low back and shoulder injuries as a direct result of the accident resulting in 10% permanent partial disability of his neck. Plaintiff further alleged that the tortfeasor was underinsured, entitling him to underinsured motorist benefits. Defendant contended that plaintiff’s injuries were not proximately related to the accident and that plaintiff was exaggerating the extent of his injuries.
Plaintiff Profile: Plaintiff was a 54 year old married white male who was employed as an electrical engineer.
Alleged Injury: Soft tissue neck, low back and shoulder injuries resulting in 10% permanent partial disability of neck and possible thoracic outlet syndrome. Plaintiff claimed $10,000 in medical specials and $3,400 in lost income.
Defendant'd Expert: Scott Green, M.D. - Orthopedist - Danielson, CT
Settlement Efforts: Last Demand: $100,000 ; Last Offer: $50,000
Judge: Samuel J. Sferrazza Date of Verdict: 7/28/99
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): Brian Prucker, Rockville
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Jan C. Trendowski, Centerbrook
Jury Deliberations: 1 hour
Verdict: $17,500 less $20,000 setoff prior to settlement yielded a net verdict of $0. Breakdown: $13,400 economic damages and $4,100 non-economic damages.